A Critical Account of Article 106(2) TFEU: Government Failure in Public Service Provision

Description

A Critical Account of Article 106(2) TFEU: Government Failure in Public Service Provision offers a sceptical perspective on how EU law applies to public services. Article 106(2) provides that other Treaty rules may be disapplied in order to sustain a Service of General Economic Interest (SGEI). In rhetorical terms, Article 106(2) is framed as a strict exception. As a result, Article 106(2) is often presented as a threat to Europe’s public service tradition. This book challenges those shibboleths by using the concept of government failure. It is concerned with instances of government intervention that are unnecessary, generate avoidable inefficiencies, or that can be bettered so as to realise general interest goals more efficaciously. As an element of the government failure critique, a market feasibility test incorporating the concept of market failure is used to expose laxity in the review of general interests under Article 106(2). Complementing that, the process of disapplying other Treaty rules under Article 106(2) is shown to have evolved from being strict to being highly indulgent of SGEI providers, with a relatively recent but only partial correction post Altmark. Overall, the strict exception label for Article 106(2) does not hold. Moreover, it is contingent and presents no legitimate general interest related threat to the organisation and delivery of public services. A comprehensive re-orientation of Article 106(2) on issues of proof is required, as is greater reliance on market counterfactuals, and much more careful separation of objectives and means in SGEI operation and design. Through these measures, the toleration of government failure can be stemmed and Article 106(2)’s contingency reduced. Volume 18 in the series Hart Studies in Competition Law Foreword Preface Contents Case Law, Commission Decisions, Legislation, EU Documents, Other Documents 1. In the General Interest? A. Introduction B. The Nature of the Problem C. The Mechanics of Article 106(2) D. The Essence of Government Failure and its Cost E. This Book 2. The Pathology of Government Failure A. Introduction B. Government Failure and Market Failure C. The Constitutional Grounding for Government Failure Control Under Article 106(2) D. Approaches to Government Failure E. Government Failure Under Article 106(2) F. Conclusions 3. The Contestation and Indeterminacy of Article 106(2) A. Introduction B. The Political, Constitutional and Administrative Battleground C. Accounts of Article 106(2) D. Conclusions 4. A Most Contingent Exemption A. Introduction B. Contestation—The Scope of Article 106(2) Ratione Materiae C. Competition—The Free Movement Derogations D. Subordination—The State Aid Rules E. Conclusions 5. Government Failure in Assessing Market Feasibility A. Introduction B. Telecommunications C. Environmental Protection D. Broadcasting E. Conclusions 6. Government Failure in Disapplication Review A. Introduction B. The First Phase—The Strict Exception C. The Second Phase—Permissive Derogation D. The Third Phase—Partial Revival E. Conclusions 7. Contours of a Better Exemption A. Introduction B. Government Failure Redux C. Proposals for a Reorientation of the Law with Respect to SGEIs D. Concluding Observations Bibliography Index